Tag Archives: stutter

Shakin’ All Over, number 7: Kenny Rogers and First Edition, ‘Ruby, don’t take your love to town’

It’s hard to love a man whose legs are bent and paralysed.

SAO cover lo resA second entry (like no. 10, The Who’s Tommy) not from disability as such but about it. A song that confirms ‘the ideology of ability’ (Tobin Siebers’ brilliant idea, from Disability Theory).  Doesn’t actually figure that much in the book, only a couple of times, and on both occasions in relation to some other point being discussed. But this song really stayed with me once I’d found it, and I must have watched this great version from 1969 fifty times or more. Here it is brought in in the context of discussing stuttering, vocal disfluency as disability and as marker of disability in lyrical pop.

… Emblematic here is the case of American country singer and songwriter Mel Tillis, who made a career in large part from the dynamic facilitative shift from spoken disfluency to sung fluency, including performing that shift on stage as he moved between inter-song comedic p-p-patter (often narratives about stuttering) and musical lyric. He had a casual neurological explanation: ‘you know, music comes from one side of your brain and your speech from the other side’. Tillis released an album in 1975 entitled M-M-Mel, called his female backing group the Stutterettes, wrote an autobiography entitled Stuttering Boy, and has a website that instructs viewers to click the button to get ‘To the N-N-Next Page!’ He frequently observed that his stutter (one of the stories is that it was the result of a childhood bout of malaria) was the root of and route to his success, and felt comfortable enough late in his highly profitable country career to accept the public role of honorary chairman for the Stuttering Foundation of America. He never stuttered in song.


In one of those intriguing crip crossovers that I have found to be surprisingly common in researching disability in popular music, as a songwriter Tillis’s biggest early hit was ‘Ruby, don’t take your love to town’, first in 1967 for Johnny Darrell and then again only two years later for Kenny Rogers and First Edition. It is a song of disability experience, narrating from his first person perspective the emasculated and desexualised transformation of the unnamed military veteran returned home from ‘that crazy Asian war’, and its impact on the domestic sphere where he is now trapped and from which Ruby, his wife, escapes nightly for sexual fulfilment. He is diminished and she is dissatisfied, since, after all, ‘It’s hard to love a man whose legs are bent and paralyzed’. Indeed, the vet cannot even manage the soldier’s trained solution—killing the object: ‘If I could move I’d get my gun and put her in the ground’. In the 1969 First Edition version, Rogers’ repressed vocal delivery adds tremendously to the drama, and the dropping out of the guitars for a percussive break near the end (‘the slamming of the door’) strips it even further down, bare. We cannot and should not ignore the fact that this extraordinarily popular and (genderedly problematically) powerful song of male disability, twice a hit during the time of the Vietnam War, of course, was written by a disabled man, a man used to negotiating the mockery and rejection that followed his stutter, his every word.

Share Button

Shakin’ All Over, number 10: The Who, Tommy

SAO cover lo res… In the book we will see that some musical acts explore and return to tropes of disability over lengthy pop careers. So, rather than disability being a distasteful or unuttered subject, it is, maybe surprisingly, centre stage in some of rock’s pleasure dome. To offer one illustrative example,

  • English rock group the Who stuttered the attitudinal voice of English youth in 1964’s ‘My generation’ (‘People try to put us d-d-down’). The stutter forms part of the argument around my notion of mal canto, speech disfluency and how, if at all, one might sing or voice a disabled body.
  • The Who sang and acted ‘That deaf dumb and blind kid [who] sure plays a mean pinball’ in 1969, and then the film Tommy in 1975, which includes that extraordinary, disquieting scene featuring Eric Clapton singing and playing ‘Eyesight to the blind’ in the church. The congregation consists of the institutionalised blind and people in wheelchairs; they must touch the icon–a statue of Marilyn Monroe–in the hope of a cure…. Confused satire? Ideology of ability?
  • Guitarist Pete Townsend was widely reported when he spoke out in 2006 about the experience and the dangers of rock music-induced hearing loss: ‘I have unwittingly helped to invent and refine a type of music that makes its principal proponents deaf’. (‘One word from [Marilyn’s] lips and the deaf can hear’? Hmm)

From youthful stutter to a hearing impairment more readily associated with older people, from the band that first sang, when they were young, ‘I hope I die before I grow old’ (it didn’t happen, not to the songwriter or the singer, anyway): cripping the Who offers us a different set of insights into the band’s body of work across the decades, which is also to do with refiguring the generational pull of youthful pop and rock. As singer Roger Daltrey said in 2006: ‘Can you see us onstage in wheelchairs?… It will still be us, still be the same music…. Pete may have trouble with the guitars, I suppose. He does like to jump around’.

Share Button